End of Near Century Old Naval Mystery Brings Family Together

The crewmembers of the USS Conestoga disappeared in 1921 at sea. 95 years later, NOAA found the boat on the coast of San Francisco, California. Photo courtesy of NOAA.

WASHINGTON –Edward Wilson, a mere 19, was one of several African-American crewmembers aboard the USS Conestoga when it mysteriously disappeared at sea after it departed March 25, 1921, from San Francisco for Hawaii.

For nearly a century, what happened to the 56-member crew has been a puzzling footnote in U.S. Navy history.  Williams’ relatives, Annika Cropper and Cynthia Thomas, barely knew he existed, much less his fate.

Now, the 95-year-old mystery has been solved. The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) announced during a special memorial for its crew in Washington last week (March 23) it has found the shipwreck off the coast of San Francisco.

Ironically, the USS Conestoga was one of the first times African Americans were ever allowed on a Navy vessel, a retired general at the event said.

Second cousins Annika Cropper and Cynthia Thomas met each other for
the first time at the memorial service for their great-uncle Edward Wilson
and other crewmembers of the USS Conestoga.
Photo courtesy of NOAA.

Cropper and Thomas were the only African Americans  among the crowd of crewmembers’ families sitting in the memorial’s Naval Heritage Center.

Cropper, who works in Los Angeles, happened to be in Washington when NOAA reached out to inform her that the ship on which her great uncle disappeared so long ago had been found. She said she knew very little about Wilson, other than the fact he and her grandmother were close.

“My grandmother actually named one of her children Edward and called him Eddie,” she said. “I’m sure she always wondered what happened to him.”

Like Cropper, Thomas knew very little about her great-uncle. Her grandmother was only around 12-years-old when Wilson left for the Navy, she said.  Still, Thomas said was very happy to find what she called closure because of NOAA’s discovery.

“The first thing I told NOAA when they notified me is that they gave me and my family the closure that was needed,” she said. “I just hate that [my grandmother] wasn’t here to hear it herself.”

Officials said they did not know the exact reason why the boat sank, but they speculated it could have been a storm.

Edward Wilson was only 19 years old when he disappeared with the rest
of his crewmembers on the USS Conestoga.
Photo courtesy of Wilson's family.

The boat was bound for Tutuila, American Samoa, by way of Hawaii, officials said.  The Navy didn’t know it was missing until it failed to arrive in Hawaii.  The Navy carried out an expansive air and sea search, but only a battered lifeboat with the letter “C” on its bow was ever found, hundreds of miles off the expected course.

While NOAA could not provide much information on the personal lives of the crewmembers, NOAA Deputy Administrator and Vice Admiral Manson Brown spoke kindly of the crew and their legacy.

“To the officers and crew of Conestoga who slumber beneath the ocean waves, your names are now etched in our hearts,” Brown said. “Your legacy of service and sacrifice are forever recorded in the annals of American history. You will not be forgotten. Rest in peace, shipmates.”

Cropper said she didn’t anticipate feeling emotional at the event, despite the closure for her family, because she never knew Wilson, but, she said, she was wrong.

“When I got there, they gave me a nametag that has his photo on it, and I actually got emotional, because my grandmother was very close to him, and it’s a family history I don’t know much about,” she said.

Thomas said the fact that the black sailors were racial trailblazers was important to her.

“That was a real accomplishment for them to have been able to be a part of this event,” she said. “It made me feel as though he was a hero in a way, because that was a barrier he crossed that other African Americans now had the opportunity to follow.”

Perhaps one of the best parts of NOAA’s discovery for both Cropper and Thomas was the reconnection of family. The women, who are second cousins, met for the first time and vowed to bring their sides of the family together.

“I think this will actually bring about more unity in the family because Edward Wilson had multiple siblings, and I don’t know many of their families,” Cropper said. “I think this will bring the family closer, and I think everyone’s going to start connecting again.”

Thomas felt similarly, excited at the prospect of expanding her family.

“My mother also feels like we’ve found out information that was always a question in the back of our minds,” she said. “It took them 95 years, but the answers have been found and it’s done. It’s a closed door for us.”